Cedar Shingle Roofer PA

Apr 26, 2023

If you are considering a new roof for your home, one of the most significant choices you will have to make is what type of material you want. Shingle Roofing in PA is a popular choice, and you can choose between Asphalt Shingle or Cedar Shakes. Both of these options look beautiful and achieve the protection and weatherproofing that a roof is expected to provide, so how do you choose which one is the best option for your home? Let's take a closer look at both types of shingle roofing in PA to help make that decision a little easier!

What Is The Difference Between Asphalt Shingles & Cedar Shakes?

When comparing these two types of shingle roofing in PA, the key point to note is that asphalt shingles and cedar shakes are made of two very different materials! Cedar shakes are cut from real wood, whereas Asphalt shingles are made from fiberglass, asphalt, and other organic materials. This means that the two different types of shingle roofing in PA will offer different aesthetic looks. A roof that uses cedar shakes often has a more natural, rustic look since the shingles will age and weather over time and often vary in thickness and width. In comparison, asphalt shingles are more uniform and offer a smoother, modern aesthetic that some homeowners prefer.

A Closer Look at Asphalt Shingles

During manufacturing, asphalt shingles are built on a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt-based filler heated to around 400 degrees. This filler is poured over the fiberglass mat to create the shingle's base. A layer of crushed rock is then applied and coated with a ceramic material to create the desired color and to make the surface weather-resistant. A final layer of sand is applied, and the entire mat is put through a process to bind everything together before the shingles are cut to size. Asphalt shingles can be produced in a wide range of colors and shapes, allowing for versatile designs using this type of shingle roofing in PA.

Let's Talk About Cedar Shakes

One of the big differences between asphalt shingles and cedar shakes is that the cedar shakes are split from natural logs. The shakes are individually cut and shaped, which gives a more unique look. They can be produced in varying thicknesses depending on the grain of the tree being used and may be resawn to create a smoother, more uniform texture that helps them lay flat when installed. However, some homeowners prefer the rougher, more natural texture.

Pros & Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Let's talk about the pros and cons of choosing asphalt shingle roofing in PA. Over the years, asphalt shingles have become a very popular choice among homeowners because they offer many advantages. Some of these include:

  • A reasonably long life expectancy
  • Wide variety of color and pattern options
  • Affordable pricing
  • Energy efficiency
  • Some brands have Class A fire rating
  • Most brands are impact rated for hail and other objects
  • Strong wind rating
  • Versatile and can be installed on most styles of roof

However, despite the many advantages of asphalt shingles, like everything in life, there are also some drawbacks to consider. Although they have a reasonable lifespan, asphalt shingles are not as durable as other materials and may need replacing after around 20 years. They are prone to cracking which may allow leaks, and if you are in an area with heavy rain and wind, you may see substantial granular loss over time.

Pros & Cons of Cedar Shakes

Cedar roofing has a very classic look, and as a result, it enjoys universal appeal among homeowners. Let's take a look at some of the benefits of choosing cedar shakes as your shingle roofing in PA.

  • A lifespan of up to 30 years when properly maintained
  • Naturally resistant to pests and insects
  • Allow better airflow than some other materials to reduce moisture build-up
  • Naturally insulating which can reduce heating and cooling costs
  • Impact and wind resistant
  • Will boost curb appeal, thus increasing your home's value.

On the flip side, one downside of cedar shakes is that they are more susceptible to fire than asphalt shingles unless they are treated with a fire retardant. They are also the more expensive option and need additional maintenance since every two to four years; you will want to clean them to remove moss and other organic matter.

How to Make Your Choice

So, armed with this information, how do you make your final choice? We recommend looking at the pros and cons of each type of shingle roofing in PA and pinpointing which features are most important to you and if any disadvantages would be a deal breaker for you. This will give you a better idea of which option you prefer. You can also discuss your options with an experienced shingle roofer who will be able to provide their own recommendations based on the size and style of your property.


Staying on Top of Things

Founded in 1986, Gillespie Contracting Inc is a family run professional Cedar roofer in Chester Springs, PA and sheet metal fabrication company. We have been serving Southeast Pennsylvania since 1986 providing roofing, siding, gutter systems, metal fabrication, and exterior home maintenance. If you are in need of a cedar or slate roofer in Chester Springs, PA why not get in touch by calling 610.601-6285 today.